Why now, and why more oftenThe rock was being held together by cold
The mechanism has a name and a literature. Permafrost, ground that has stayed frozen year-round, acts as cement in high rock faces, and glacier ice acts as a buttress against them. Warming removes both at once.
More than 70% of documented rock-ice avalanches in High Mountain Asia begin in zones of probable permafrost, and 65% start where ground temperatures already exceed −1.5 °C. That is not a marginal statistic; it means the failures are concentrating precisely where the freezing point is being crossed.
As a glacier retreats, the rock wall it was pressed against loses its support and is exposed to air temperature, rain and repeated freeze-thaw cycling for the first time in centuries. The wall does not fail immediately. It fails at some unpredictable later point, which is what makes this hazard so difficult: the cause is decades of warming, and the trigger is a Tuesday morning.
The long tail is the part that gets least attention. Even if warming is held to 1.5 °C, permafrost at depth continues to thaw for centuries. The supply of destabilised faces above Himalayan valleys is going to keep increasing across the working lifetime of every hydropower plant currently being financed in Nepal.
Honest caveat: no attribution study has tied this specific avalanche to climate change, and researchers investigating it have been careful to say so, while noting unusually warm satellite observations and reduced snow cover beforehand. The mechanism is well established. This one event is not yet proof of it.
47
Potentially dangerous glacial lakes
Across the Koshi, Gandaki and Karnali basins: 25 in the Tibet Autonomous Region of China, 21 in Nepal, 1 in India. 42 of the 47 sit in the Koshi basin alone. Identified and ranked in a joint ICIMOD–UNDP inventory published on 7 September 2020, six years before this flood.
70%+
Rock-ice avalanches starting in permafrost
More than 70% of documented rock-ice avalanches in High Mountain Asia begin in zones of probable permafrost, and 65% start where ground temperatures exceed −1.5 °C. As permafrost warms, the rock faces it was holding together stop being held together.